Thoughts on Doctor Who: Flux chapter 3…
Once, Upon Time
Strands. Woven together. Threads. Timestreams.
Four of the plotstrands that Chibnall has spun are brought together by this chapter.
The Fugitive Doctor. The Division. Old Swarm. The Temple of Atropos.
The past Doctor of the Division versus Old Swarm at the Temple of Atropos. (Mirrored by the current Doctor of the TARDIS versus new Swarm at the Temple of Atropos. And that’s only one of five mini-stories of this episode. Two have backstory for the two new companions, one features Yaz, the fifth is Bel’s Story, which has New Adventures vibes.)
A sigh of relief then as these four plotstrands of previous episodes combine to a satifying whole, a glimpse of the mystery of the forgotten incarnations of the Doctor.
If that lessens the mystery slightly there are two scenes which add new mysteries. This chapter continues the brilliant & fresh new style of overlapping puzzles though these two scenes elevate it to greatness.
Scene one. Old Swarm has a delightfully baroque speech about “the battle between Time and Space”, “the Founding Conflict”. (More New Adventures vibes.) Time triumphing over Space? Entropy. Things fall apart.
Scene two. The very exciting casting of Barbara Flynn as Awsok (say the credits), a figure seemingly manipulating both the Flux (a “spatial event”) and Time, through Swarm & Flux. Enigmatic.
The Flux, “it was made… Because of you” she tells the Doctor.
Behind her the scenery, some strands. Some machinery. What is she tending with her dropper of liquid, a shrubbery, a beehive, some vines, the weaving of threads into cloth? A loom? That would certainly chime with the other imagery of threads or timestreams spun by the Mouri from the Temple of Atropos.
Additional Flux musings:
Although some of the earlier mysteries of Swarm (introduced as the main villain of the season) & Azure have been resolved halfway through the six chapters, there is now the mystery of what Awsok meant when she said they were “useful” – and the mystery of Awsok.
Chibnall could be delving further into Doctor Who continuity by having Awsok be a new version of the Black & White Guardians but that by itself wouldn’t be a meaningful twist for the general audience. The origin of Awsok will somehow be connected to Gallifrey or the Division (another incarnation of the Doctor?) or explained by the events of these six chapters.
Additional Doctor Who musings:
Old Swarm says “…the Division must be so compromising”, and that was part of the drama once the Division had been established last season, that the Doctor wasn’t the Doctor before they were the, err, Doctor. (The same dramatic tension of The Day of the Doctor, that one incarnation seemingly took a timeout from being the Doctor.)
However the actions of the previous incarnation of the Doctor line up with the actions of the Doctor, there’s no conflict and she and her team are saving the universe from Old Swarm, heroically.
How the Fugitive Doctor has the junkyard’s police-box TARDIS – and whether or not there is any difference between a Divison Commander running from the Division and that person being “the Doctor” – all that is still to be resolved.